Shivam Jaiswal is student at Hidayatullah National Law University

Introduction

In the 1990s, collective agreements were used to license a player’s likeness for a video game. A single static transaction. A singular commercial fee paid to feature a fixed visual representation on a physical game disc. Today, catalyzed by the advent of live-service models like ‘Ultimate Team’ in games like EAFC, the global sports gaming industry has been fundamentally transformed into a continuously updated digital ecosystem. This means that a footballer’s in-game representation is no longer a mere static image. Instead, it is a continuously processed digital asset, built upon high-fidelity facial scans, motion-capture biometrics, and real-time performance tracking.

Titles like EAFC (and its Mobile version) rely heavily on collective licensing through player representative organizations such as FIFPro, domestic leagues and individual football clubs (FCs). This technological shift exposes a critical gap in traditional licensing frameworks. While athlete likenesses were traditionally governed almost exclusively by the commercial principles of intellectual property (IP) and contract law, the hyper-realistic, digital ecosystem that is modern-day sports video games like EAFC now intersects directly with the evolving data protection regimes and constitutional privacy rights, which have been brought into the fray by the processing of an athlete’s personal data, that is, their name, image and likeness (NIL). 

The Dual Nature of Image Rights

To navigate this legal friction in digital sports licensing, one must first delineate the dual nature of a modern player’s image rights. European civil law jurisdictions offer a highly evolved, codified framework for this duality, categorizing image rights into two spheres: patrimonial and extra-patrimonial rights.

In the commercial realm, patrimonial rights allow an athlete’s NIL to be alienated, licensed, and exploited for profit. This economic right is the foundation upon which publishers like EA Sports and collective unions operate. Conversely, extra-patrimonial rights encompass moral and privacy rights tied intrinsically to human dignity.

European Courts have preserved this distinction. For instance, in the landmark case of Oliver Kahn v. Electronic Arts, the German Courts ruled that the legendary goalkeeper’s fundamental personality rights superseded EA’s unapproved commercial exploitation. Similarly, courts have identified image and personality rights to be an intimate component of privacy rights under Article 9 and Article 10 of the French and the Italian Civil Codes, respectively.

In contrast to this codified European model, India lacks a specific statute governing image rights. It instead relies on a common law combination of IP and torts law. While early jurisprudence established the right to publicity as a commercial asset, recent rulings by the Delhi High Court have aggressively expanded this framework to combat unauthorized digital exploitation. In landmark injunctions protecting personality rights of actors such as Anil Kapoor and Jackie Shroff, the Court ruled that the unauthorized use of a celebrity’s name, voice, image, and distinct persona, by technological means such as artificial intelligence (AI) and digital cloning, violated their personality rights, which were identified to be flowing from the fundamental right to privacy, and its commercial exploitation. By doing so, the Court recognized that a digital likeness is not merely an alienable commercial property, but that this commercial nature of personality rights in itself is protected under the Fundamental Right of the right to privacy under Article 21.

Consequently, the creation of modern digital avatars forces a convergence of these two legal traditions. Rendering a live-service digital player representation often relies on the continuing use of athlete-specific biometric data, including facial images, wearable-derived measurements, and other physical or physiological metrics. While the commercial branding (names used on the jersey and for the player) can be protected as a patrimonial right, the underlying biometric data strictly constitutes an extra-patrimonial privacy right.

Unlike IP, which facilitates commercial alienation, data protection frameworks view biometric data as an inalienable extension of personhood. Therefore, while personality and image rights principles empower a publisher to commercially exploit a brand, they do not inherently authorize the continuous processing of biometric inputs forming the digital player representation. Recognizing this dichotomy is crucial. Possessing a commercial contract to exploit a player’s brand does not automatically grant a perpetual right to actively process their biometric data.

Constitutional Foundation

The European recognition of extra-patrimonial rights is not alien to Indian jurisprudence. In the landmark judgment of Justice KS Puttaswamy (Retd) v Union of India, the Supreme Court recognized right to privacy as an intrinsic part of the fundamental right to life and personal liberty under Article 21. When delineating the essential nature of this right, the Court noted that privacy safeguards the “inner sphere” of the individual, preserving their “core identity, autonomy, and the right to be left alone.”

This constitutional framework seemingly bridges the gap between commercial IP and human rights. By extending this right to informational privacy, the Court recognized the principle that an individual has the right to exercise control over the processing of their personal data, referred to as “informational self-determination.”

When applied to live-service gaming ecosystems such as EAFC, the constitutional implication is profound. The facial scans and real-time physical metrics input by publishers to create hyper-realistic digital representation of a footballer can be understood to be the athlete’s “inner sphere.” Therefore, the athlete’s right to control this data has a constitutional force, operating against its commercial exploitation. While a player may sign a collective agreement to monetise their brand, a standard commercial IP contract cannot permanently dissolve a fundamental constitutional right.

The Statutory Consent Mechanism

Modern data protection regimes have operationalized this informational self-determination through legislative frameworks. This, in turn, threatens the validity of perpetual IP licensing in the modern digital ecosystems such as EAFC.

India’s Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (DPDPA) and its associated rules operate on a rigorous notice and consent model. Sections 5 and 6 of DPDPA mandate free, specific, informed and unambiguous consent for processing of any personal data, to be obtained through a notice. Furthermore, Section 6(4) provides the Data Principal (in this case the athlete) with a right to withdraw their consent at any time, legally compelling the Data Fiduciary (in this case the publishers) to stop processing the Data Principal’s personal data.

This domestic framework mirrors the mature jurisprudential foundation laid down by the European Union’s (EU’s) General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). The GDPR elevates this legal friction by explicitly classifying biometric data as a “special category” under Article 9. This subjects the data to heightened protection, generally prohibiting its processing without explicit affirmative consent. Similar to the Indian statute, Article 7(3) of the GDPR guarantees a right of withdrawal.

In defense of their live-service ecosystems, publishers frequently argue that consent is lawfully secured through collective bargaining agreements negotiated by unions like FIFPro or individual FCs. However, this defense may fail the stringent statutory threshold of both privacy regimes. A commercial contract or a union negotiated agreement may not satisfy the legal requirement for “specific, informed, and freely given” consent to continuously process sensitive biometric data for a third-party video game.

Commercial Dispute and Live-Service Reality

This tension between collective IP licensing and individual extra-patrimonial right, constitutes an active, multi-million-dollar commercial crisis. The Zlatan Ibrahimovic dispute highlighted this very crisis.

Notable footballers and football icons Ibrahimovic and Gareth Bale publicly challenged EA Sports, questioning its legal authority to exploit their NIL, based on blanket union agreements, of which they were not even a part, without their consent. This systemic vulnerability is not confined to European football. Recent clashes between the International Cricket Council (ICC) and the World Cricketers’ Association (WCA) over the unapproved exploitation of player image rights in officially sanctioned mobile cricket games demonstrate that the global gaming industry’s reliance on implied, collective consent is collapsing across all sports. 

The sports gaming industry heavily favors these collective agreements because acquiring individual, revocable consent from thousands of athletes would be operationally very burdensome. Publishers argue that requiring direct, statutory consent from every athlete would render the global sports gaming ecosystem unworkable. They further argue that removing a player mid-cycle would be technically devastating for the product, as the gaming community as a whole appreciates a hyper-realistic video game, up-to-date with all their favorite and notable sports stars.

However, the reality of the live-service model actually weaponizes the privacy argument against the publishers. Because games like EAFC are updated regularly with live statistical changes, new events and players, and dynamic animations, the developer is engaged in the continuous, active processing of the player’s personal data. It becomes an ongoing exploitation instead of a one-time publication. Since the data processing is continuous, the sword of the statutory right of withdrawal under the DPDPA or GDPR hangs perpetually over the publishers’ heads.

The Biometric Severability Model

Left unchecked, this symbolic Damocles’ Sword of statutory consent poses a significant threat to the live-service gaming ecosystem. Reconciling the two would require a sophisticated contractual mechanism rather than relying on outdated instruments such as collective agreements. An approach that could effectively help achieve this equilibrium is the adoption of a Biometric Severability Model. Rather than viewing an athlete’s likeness as a singular commercial asset, sports contracts must incorporate explicit severability clauses that partition it into two:

  • Commercial Brand (Patrimonial Rights): This tier would govern the traditional property attributes such as the player’s name, club affiliation, and other metrics. Because these metrics do not constitute sensitive biometric information, their remaining bound to long-term commercial contracts and collective bargaining agreements would not pose any problems.
  • Biometric Data Processing (Extra-Patrimonial Rights): This tier would govern exclusively the obtaining and processing of an athlete’s sensitive biometric data, such as the high-fidelity facial scans and motion-capture data. This right would remain strictly subject to statutory data protection frameworks and the athlete’s right of withdrawal.

This framework is anchored in the broader doctrine of contractual severability, affirmed in landmark rulings such as the UK Supreme Court’s decision in Tillman v Egon Zehnder Ltd and the Indian Supreme Court’s ruling in Shin Satellite Public Co Ltd v Jain Studios Ltd. These cases establish that an unenforceable or invalid clause can be legally severed to save the broader commercial agreement, provided the excision does not fundamentally alter the core substance of the contract. Similarly, the withdrawal of biometric consent should not void the broader IP license.

When an athlete exercises their statutory right to withdraw consent under Section 6(4) of India’s Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (DPDPA) or Article 7(3) of the EU’s GDPR, the doctrine operationalizes a multi-stage fallback:

  1. Immediate Biometric Cessation: In strict compliance with DPDPA Section 6(6) and GDPR Article 9(2)(a), the publisher immediately halts the active processing, rendering, and updating of the athlete’s biometric facial scans and physical animations.
  2. Execution of Patrimonial Continuity: Because the contract explicitly severs the IP license from data consent, the Commercial Brand Right remains valid. The publisher is contractually authorized to replace the scrubbed biometric asset with a generic, non-identifiable digital character.

Ultimately, this framework ensures that data protection obligations are meticulously honored without demanding the all-or-nothing destruction of modern gaming platforms.

Conclusion

Traditional collective IP licenses are falling short of the statutory thresholds with the advent of live-service gaming. As elite athletes become increasingly sophisticated in negotiating their image rights, game publishers must not keep ignoring statutory data privacy regimes that guarantee the fundamental right to information self-determination.

The Biometric Severability Model provides a pragmatic bridge between these competing legal paradigms. By contractually severing the patrimonial commercial branding right from the extra-patrimonial biometric processing right, the industry can operationalize consent withdrawal without destroying multi-million-dollar platforms serving millions of players worldwide. Thus, while an athlete’s name and statistics may be alienable commodities, their digital likeness remains an extension of their fundamental privacy.

Share this post